Economics News Articles: February 2006

 

February is a short month, but there is never any shortage of economics news. This month we look at a wide range of topics ranging from one that may bring back some bad driving memories for you ("Teaching white van man to drive" News Item 7) to the broader issue of globalisation. The publication of the Thomas Friedman book "The World is Flat" has raised the tenor of the debate about globalisation amongst economists, though contrary to the impression given by the title, there is little in it to encourage members of the Flat Earth Society. We look at the issue of globalisation from speeches at the Davos Economic Forum and also through a new BBC World Service series "The New Rules of the Game" (see News Item 15) which can also be downloaded as a podcast. The election of Hamas in Palestine has sparked a political debate and in News Item 9 we look at the economic situation inherited by Hamas. We also look at the decision by Peter Mandelson, The EU Trade Commissioner, to impose duties on leather shoes coming from China and the Far East. He has done this in the face of what he describes as compelling evidence of dumping (see News Item 13).
 

As usual, I hope that you find the articles informative and useful for your studies. I also hope that you enjoy reading them and answering the questions.

Andy Beharrell

 Contents 
1. Podtastic - the iPod brand
2. Not so Krafty - job losses at Kraft
3. The mystery of the rude waiter
4. Who benefits from the bigger productivity pie?
5. Wal-Mart - creating or destroying jobs?
6. Is there space for waste or is it a waste of space looking?
7. Training 'white van man' to drive
8. GDP - a grossly distorted picture?
9. Countering the Palestinian financial crisis
10. The relentless rise of the emerging economies
11. How great was Greenspan? The end of an era
12. Scrap the council tax?
13. Who will foot the bill for duties on shoes?
14. America's dark matter - where has it gone?
15. Falling off the edge of a flat earth?

News Item 1: Podtastic - the iPod brand


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th and 6th edition), Chapter 2
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapters 1, 2
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapters 4, 5, 15
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapters 2, 6
 
February 2006 marked the time that the billionth song was downloaded from Apple's iTunes service. The success of this service and the iPod music player has turned the iPod into a major brand. Apple is starting to use the success of the brand as part of the marketing strategy for its computers and other products as it becomes clear that it will be easier to convert iPod users away from their PCs.

Podtastic The Economist (12/1/06)

Questions
1. What are the main determinants of demand for iPods?
2. What impact will the development of the iPod as a super-brand have on the price elasticity of demand for iPods?
3. What would you expect the value of the cross elasticity of demand for Apple Macs to be with respect to the price of PCs? What could Apple do to change this value?

Go back to contents


News Item 2: Not so Krafty - job losses at Kraft


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th and 6th edition), Chapters 5, 7
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapters 3, 4
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapters 9, 12, 15
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapters 4, 5, 6
 
As part of a major restructuring programme Kraft Foods announced this month that it would be closing up to 20 production plants and reducing its workforce by up to 8%. This amounts to the elimination of around 8,000 jobs. These job cuts are on top of 5,000 already announced in January 2004. The aim is to achieve savings of around $700 million a year.

Kraft to cut 8,000 jobs and 20 factories The Age (31/1/06)
Kraft foods to eliminate 8,000 jobs Business Week (30/1/06)

Questions
1. How will the restructuring proposed by Kraft Foods affect costs? Demonstrate the effects on a diagram or diagrams.
2. Using diagrams as appropriate, show the impact of the restructuring on the equilibrium price and level of output of Kraft Foods.
3. Discuss possible reasons for the restructuring announced by Kraft Foods.

Go back to contents


News Item 3: The mystery of the rude waiter


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th and 6th edition), Chapter 7
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapter 4
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapter 17
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapter 5
 
Tim Harford's favourite restaurant has a rude waiter. This is not normally a recommendation for a restaurant, but in the article below from Slate, he muses over whether this may a deliberate strategy on the part of the restaurant. So, as the article puts it, "Why would a restaurant deliberately sabotage the dining experience?"

The mystery of the rude waiter MSN Slate (21/1/06)

Questions
1. Discuss whether the rude waiter is really a price discrimination strategy as suggested by Tim Harford.
2. What conditions need to be fulfilled for price discrimination to be effective? Are these conditions fulfilled in the restaurant described? 
3. Using diagrams as appropriate, explain why Adobe chose to produce Photoshop Elements as well as Photoshop (as referred to in the article).

Go back to contents


News Item 4: Who benefits from the bigger productivity pie?


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th and 6th edition), Chapters 9, 10, 21
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapters 5, 10
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapters 18, 31
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapters 7, 10
 
American productivity growth has always been looked at from this side of the pond with a degree of envy. British workers might reasonably have assumed that their US counterparts were benefiting from higher wages as a result of the productivity gains, but has this really been happening? The article below from The Economist considers who has benefited from the growth in US productivity and, perhaps not surprisingly, the workers may not have been the main beneficiaries.
Dividing the pie The Economist (2/2/06)
Questions
1. What are the main factors that have led to the productivity gains experienced by the US economy?
2. Summarise the main arguments in the article relating to the division of the productivity growth between owners and workers.
3. What impact is the productivity growth likely to have on the distribution of income and wealth?

Go back to contents


News Item 5: Wal-Mart - creating or destroying jobs?


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th and 6th edition), Chapter 9
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapter 5
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapter 18
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapter 7
 
Wal-Mart is now the world's largest company by sales. It sold $312.4 billion worth of goods in its last financial year. That makes it larger than a significant number of world economies. Its impact on employment in areas where it operates is equally significant, but is it positive or negative? The company will always argue that it creates jobs in the area it moves into, but how many jobs are destroyed as a result and, with global supply-chains, how many jobs are moved overseas? The article below from The Economist tries to make some sense of the 'Wal-Mart effect', as it has become known.
Opening up the big box The Economist (23/2/06)
Questions
1. Discuss the advantages and disadvantages for a community of Wal-Mart opening a store in the area.
2. Assess the impact that the opening of a store will have on the local labour market.
3. What impact has the growth of Wal-Mart had on the competitiveness in the 'grocery' market in the USA? Discuss whether this is positive or negative for consumers.

Go back to contents


News Item 6: Is there space for waste or is it a waste of space looking?


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th and 6th edition), Chapters 11, 12
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapter 6
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapters 20, 22
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapter 8
 
The UK generates around 400m tonnes of waste a year. According to the BBC article linked to below, this is enough to fill the Albert Hall every two hours, though we can safely presume that they haven't tested this assertion! There has long been a debate on the best way to deal with this waste, but the government has signaled a change in approach with a shift towards incineration of waste. The aim is to incinerate 25% of waste by 2020. This has ignited (excuse the pun) further debate and the building of new incinerators is sure to lead to an outbreak of NIMBYism (Not In My Backyard).
UK 'refuseniks' tackle Big Waste BBC News (25/1/06)
Questions
1. What external costs result from the growth in waste? How do these external costs affect the socially optimum level of waste?
2. According to Dominic Moran, senior environmental economist at the Scottish Agricultural College, "The holy grail is to let the market sort out how it wants to operate - for example, having markets in waste trading." Discuss how this approach will help reduce the environmental impact of the growth in waste.
3. Evaluate two policy options available to the government to tackle the growth in the level of waste.

Go back to contents


News Item 7: Training 'white van man' to drive


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th and 6th edition), Chapter 12
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapter 6
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapters 20, 22
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapter 8
 
We have all come across the renowned sub-species "White Van Man". However, in an attempt to reduce the problems caused by White Van Man, the government is to train 200 advanced driving instructors to give free driving lessons for 3,500 drivers of light goods vehicles.
Teaching 'white van man' to drive Guardian (25/1/06)
Questions
1. What are the private costs and external costs that result from the use of 'white vans'?
2. What private and external benefits does the government hope will arise from the free driving lessons being offered to van drivers?
3. Discuss whether the growth in van deliveries to homes resulting from the growth in online shopping will have a net positive or negative environmental impact.

Go back to contents


News Item 8: GDP - a grossly distorted picture?


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th and 6th edition), Chapter 13
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapter 7
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapter 26
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapter 9
 
The Holy Grail of economic policy tends to be economic growth and we measure this by looking at the growth in GDP. However, GDP has significant flaws as a measure of economic development and welfare. So is this the best way to measure progress? The article linked to below from The Economist considers some of these flaws and looks at other factors that need to be taken into account to give a better measure of economic welfare.

Grossly distorted picture The Economist (9/2/06)

Questions
1. Explain the main problems with using GDP as a measure of economic welfare.
2. What other alternative measures are available to give an improved measurement of economic welfare?
3. On the Friends of the Earth web site, you can make your own Index of Sustainable Economic Welfare. Experiment with changing variables to see the impact on the difference between GDP and the ISEW. What are the most important factors that lead to divergence between GDP and the ISEW?

Go back to contents


News Item 9: Countering the Palestinian financial crisis


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th edition), Chapters 13, 14, 20, 21; (6th edition), Chapters 13, 14, 19, 20
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapters 7, 8, 10
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapters 26, 29
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapters 9, 10
 
The election of Hamas as the new government in Palestine has led to a political crisis, but an economic crisis looms as well. The decision of the Israelis to suspend payments to the Palestinian Authority has cut off a significant proportion of their revenues. This will have a dramatic effect on an economy that is already struggling with 27% unemployment and where GDP has fallen by 38% since 1999.
Palestinians 'face financial crisis' BBC News (21/2/06)
Questions
1. Discuss the likely impact on the Palestinian economy of the suspension of the Israeli payments.
2. Explain how the payments that have been frozen differ from foreign aid payments. Assess the likely impact of a reduction in foreign aid to the Palestinian Authority.
3. Evaluate the policy options available to the new Hamas government to improve the performance of the Palestinian economy? What constraints does it face in trying to implement these policies?

Go back to contents


News Item 10: The relentless rise of the emerging economies


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th edition), Chapters 22, 25, 26; (6th edition), Chapters 21, 25, 26
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapters 10, 12
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapters 26, 29
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapter 11
 
For many years the major industrialised economies (often described as 'first-world economies') have dominated world production and consumption. However, emerging economies in the Far East and Asia are starting to close the gap. With economic growth rates significantly higher than those of the first-world, the gap may start to close quickly and the article below from The Economist assess some of the reasons for these changes.
Climbing back The Economist (19/1/05)
Questions
1. How has The Economist defined 'emerging economies'? Is this an appropriate definition?
2. What are the main factors that have led to the rapid growth experienced by many of the emerging economies?
3. What is meant by measuring GDP at PPP rates? What problems might arise from using this measure of GDP to compare performance between economies?

Go back to contents


News Item 11: How great was Greenspan? The end of an era


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th edition), Chapter 20; (6th edition), Chapter 19
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapter 9
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapters 28, 30
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapter 10
 
At the end of January 2006 Alan Greenspan retired as Chairman of the US Federal Reserve (the US equivalent of the Bank of England) after a remarkable 18 year tenure. The job made him one of the most powerful men in the world and during those years he guided the US economy through the 1987 Stock Market crash, the financial crisis in Asia and the dotcom boom bubble in 2000. He was very widely respected in policy-making circles and is perhaps regarded as a remarkable central banker. But what sort of legacy has he left for his successor, Ben Bernanke? The articles below look at the situation from a range of perspectives.

Deficits could harm Greenspan's legacy BBC News (29/12/05)
It is unwise to say 'No' to Chairman Al MSN Slate (30/1/06)
Monetary myopia The Economist (12/1/06)
Challenges ahead for US economy BBC News (2/1/06)

Questions
1. Use the articles linked above and some wider web research to assess Alan Greenspan's tenure as Chairman of the Federal Reserve.
2. The article from The Economist linked to above is critical of Mr. Greenspan's failure to restrain the Stock Market bubble. Critically assess the arguments.
3. What have been the main monetary policy tools during Mr. Greenspan's tenure and how do these differ from those used by the Bank of England?

Go back to contents


News Item 12: Scrap the council tax?


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th edition), Chapters 10, 20, 22; (6th edition), Chapters 10, 19, 22
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapters 5, 8
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapters 30, 31
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapter 10
 
In a recent report the National Institute of Economic and Social Research proposes the scrapping of the council tax and replacing it with a 1% levy on the value of properties. They argue that this would be a fairer tax even though it would hit those with more valuable properties harder and that it would yield larger revenues. The proposal met with a mixed response and while it unlikely to be on any manifestos in the near future, it has helped raise once again the debate about council tax.

Replace council tax with 1% property levy - NIESR Guardian (27/1/06)

Questions
1. Explain how a 1% property levy would differ from the council tax.
2. Assess the advantages and disadvantages of the introduction of a 1% property levy. What impact is the introduction of a tax of this nature likely to have on the macroeconomic performance of the UK?
3. What other policy options are available to the government to fund local government?

Go back to contents


News Item 13: Who will foot the bill for duties on shoes?


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th and 6th edition), Chapter 23
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapter 11
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapter 24
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapter 11
 
The EU in response to what it describes as 'compelling evidence' of dumping has imposed duties of nearly 20% on shoes imported from China and Vietnam. The practice of dumping (selling products at below their average cost) is a form of protectionism and is notoriously difficult to prove, but Peter Mandelson, the EU Trade Commissioner, argued that the evidence was clear enough to impose the penalties. The industry has reacted angrily and argued that it is consumers who will pay the price of the duties as the higher costs are passed on through prices.
Mandelson under attack as Brussels plans duties of 20% on Asian show imports Guardian (24/2/06)
China dismissed EU charges of shoe dumping Business Week (24/2/06)
China anger over EU shoe ruling BBC News (24/2/06)
These shoes were made for dumping BBC News (24/2/06)
EU decision on shoe tax is biased, says China International Herald Tribune (24/2/06)
Shoe ruling is a step in wrong direction Times Online (24/2/06)
No Vietnamese footwear dumping in EU: FM spokesman Xinhua (23/2/06)
Questions
1. Explain why the practice of dumping is considered as protectionism.
2. What are the arguments for and against putting tariffs on products which are dumped on an economy?
3. What other forms of protectionism are practised by governments around the world?
4. Using diagrams as appropriate, show the likely impact on the market for shoes of the duties imposed by the EU.

Go back to contents


News Item 14: America's dark matter - where has it gone?


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th and 6th edition), Chapters 24, 25
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapters 11, 12
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapters 27, 32
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapters 11, 12
 
America's huge trade deficit has usually led economists to the conclusion that the USA is the world's biggest debtor, owing vast amounts to other countries whose inflows of investment have helped to fund the deficit. However, in the article linked to from The Economist below, two economists question this assumption and argue that in fact America is a net creditor and has more wealth than we can see. If this is the case, then where has all this overseas wealth gone?
America's dark materials The Economist (19/1/06)
Questions
1. How is a deficit on the current account of the balance of payments funded?
2. Summarise the arguments from the article about America's overseas wealth position.
3. If the article's premise is correct, what implications does this have for US macroeconomic policy?

Go back to contents


News Item 15: Falling off the edge of a flat earth?


Relevant to:
    Economics (5th and 6th edition), Chapters 25, 26
    Essentials of Economics (3rd edition), Chapter 12
    Economics for Business (3rd edition), Chapters 15, 23, 32
    The Economic Environment of Business (1st edition), Chapters 6, 12
 
The award-winning New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman's new book is called "The World is Flat". This a reference to the fact that globalisation has led to the world getting smaller and therefore he argues 'flatter'. Global supply chains for services and manufacturing require companies and countries to adapt to the new world. This mantra has been picked up by a large number of prominent businesspeople and politicians, not least Bill Gates, who gave a talk on this theme at the World Economic Forum at Davos in January 2006. The BBC has also produce a new series relating to globalisation called "The new rules of the game". These programmes can be downloaded as podcasts to listen to - follow the relevant links below for more information.

The new rules of the game (part 1) BBC News (20/2/06)
The new rules of the game (part 2) BBC News (27/2/06)
The new rules of the game (part 3) BBC News (3/3/06)
The new rules of the global game BBC News (19/2/06)
Why Bill Gates believes the world is flat BBC News (29/1/06)
BBC World Service: Globalisation BBC World Service

Questions
1. Why is the world becoming 'flatter'?
2. Discuss who the main winners and losers from globalisation are likely to be.
3. Assess the extent to which developing countries are likely to gain from globalisation.

Go back to contents