| Economics News Articles: February 2003 |
| Welcome to the February set of news
articles. The news this past month has been dominated by the possibility
of war with Iraq. Not only would a war have enormous human, political and
social consequences, but it would also affect the economies of the countries
involved and the world economy in general. In fact, the world economy is
already being affected. Worries and uncertainties about whether there will
be a war have affected business and consumer confidence. This, in turn,
has had a direct effect on both investment and consumer spending and hence
on countries' macroeconomic performance. News item 9 looks at some of these
effects.
In the UK, one of the major news items has been the introduction of congestion charging in London. This is examined in the articles under news item 7. As before, I hope that you find the articles informative and useful for your studies. I also hope that you enjoy reading them and answering the questions. |
|
John Sloman
|
| Contents |
1. Housing boom coming to an end
2. Agricultural support
3. Social capital and 'rational' behaviour
4. An explosion of pay inequality
5. Tackling poverty in the UK
6. Brown's middle way (the 'third way'?)
7. Congestion charging in London
8. Falling into recession?
9. The economic impact of war
10. Comparing US and European standards of living
11. Goodbye to the City
12. The future of pensions
13. Is the Bank of England inflation model out of date?
14. UK and Eurozone monetary policy decisions
15. Are we heading for deflation?
16. UK and US trade deficits
17. The outlook for east Asian economies
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th and 5th editions), Chapter 2 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapters 1, 2 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapters 4, 5 |
| We have looked at the housing market in previous months' news items and there have been suggestions that the rapid increases in house prices were beginning to slow down. New evidence confirms this trend. Indeed, in London and the south-east of England, they have recently fallen. Whether other parts of the country will see falling prices remains to be seen. The following articles look at the reasons for the cooling in the housing market and look ahead to what will happen in the coming months. |
Housing boom 'coming to an end' BBC News Online (20/2/03)
House price inflation to drop, says Bank of England Ananova (12/2/03)
Housing market 'heading for soft landing' Ananova (18/2//03)
| Questions | |
| 1. | Why have house price increases been slowing down rapidly in recent weeks (and in some areas actually falling)? |
| 2. | Why has the supply of houses coming on to the market increased recently? |
| 3. | What effect is the cut in interest rates by the Bank of England from 4% to 3.75% likely to have on house prices? How will the effect be influenced by (a) expectations; (b) the price elasticity of supply of houses? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th and 5th editions), Chapters 3, 23 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapters 2, 11 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapters 5, 19, 22 |
| The following linked article by Victor Keegan appeared in the Guardian of 20 February 2003. He argues that all price support and other subsidies for agriculture should be abolished and that farmers should compete in the open market as most other businesses are required to do. He criticises EU leaders for only tinkering with reform of the CAP and argues that now is a golden opportunity for abolishing subsidies, with eastern European countries set to join the EU next year - countries with large agricultural sectors. |
For some, money grows on trees
| Questions | |
| 1. | Why would abolishing price support and other subsidies be 'the nearest thing to a free lunch in the economics textbooks'? |
| 2. | How would abolishing agricultural support affect the farmers in the EU in (a) the short run; (b) the long run? (Consider both adverse and beneficial effects.) |
| 3. | If the UK has a comparative disadvantage in food production, what would happen to (a) the structure of the economy, (b) the rural community, (c) the rural environment, if agricultural support were abolished? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th and 5th editions), Chapters 1, 4, 11 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapters 1, 6 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapters 6, 19 |
| It is often assumed in simple economic models that people will behave 'rationally'. This rational behaviour is then defined as the attempt to maximise one's own self interest. Despite this selfish behaviour, however, if markets are perfect and there are no externalities, the result will be one of 'social efficiency'. The 'invisible hand' of the market will lead to the common good. But do people behave selfishly? Do we need markets to function really well in order to achieve socially efficient outcomes? Aren't people also motivated by social objectives, such as trust and commonly shared values? The following article, from The Economist of 20 February 2003, looks at the importance of trust and community values (or 'social capital') in explaining human behaviour. |
A question of trust
| Questions | |
| 1. | Why might you spend time doing things whose private costs to you outweighed the private benefits to you? |
| 2. | If people derive utility from helping others, does this mean that social behaviour and trust are merely more sophisticated forms of self-interested behaviour? |
| 3. | Give some examples of positive and negative externalities that could result from people investing in social capital. |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th and 5th editions), Chapter 10 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapter 5 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 17 |
| The following article, from the Guardian of 4 February 2003, looks at evidence from the latest New Earnings Survey published by the UK's National Statistics. It shows a widening of the pay gap in the UK in the late 1990s. During the 1990s, the before-tax pay of the lowest paid 10 per cent rose by 46 per cent, while that of the highest paid 10 per cent rose by 54 per cent. Why has this occurred and what are the policy implications? The following article from the Guardian of 4 February 2002 looks at the evidence and the arguments. |
Mind the gap
| Questions | |
| 1. | Why has the pay gap widened in the UK? Why have people at the very top seen such dramatic rises in their incomes? |
| 2. | To what extent can the minimum wage help to close the gap? |
| 3. | How could the government reduce the size of the gap and what would be consequences of attempting to do so? |
| 4. | Why would a recession narrow the gap? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th and 5th editions), Chapter 10 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapter 5 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 17 |
| The following two articles from the Guardian of 7 and 3 February 2003 look at aspects of poverty in the UK. The first examines the minimum wage and whether at current and proposed levels it makes any significant contribution to the alleviation of poverty. The second focuses on child poverty and how it has changed since the early 1990s. It asks why the the increase in social security spending since 1997 targeted at families with children has not had a bigger impact. |
Can't even spare a fiver
New Labour's poverty trap
| Questions | |
| 1. | What are the arguments for and against raising the minimum wage to (a) £5 per hour; (b) £8 per hour? |
| 2. | What are the implications for low paid workers of local authorities putting more of their services out to tender? |
| 3. | How would you explain workers in low-pay occupations receiving identical rates of pay from different employers? |
| 4. | How is the macroeconomic state of the economy likely to affect the extent of low pay? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th and 5th editions), Chapters 11, 12, 22 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapters 6, 10 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapters 19, 20, 21, 30 |
| On 3 February, Gordon Brown gave a lecture at the Social Market Foundation. In it, he focused on the strengths and weaknesses of the market and on the role of government in tackling market failures. He argued for a middle way between market fundamentalism (see October 2002 News Item 4) and centralised public ownership. The first two of the linked articles below appeared in the Guardian the following day. The third link is to the Treasury site, which gives the speech in full. |
Warning by Brown on market role
Brown's big idea
The speech in full
| Questions | |
| 1. | For what reasons, according to Gordon Brown, are market solutions in some public services inappropriate? |
| 2. | Why might the introduction of choice in health "be a mirage" and risk "creating a two-tier system"? |
| 3. | Click on the full speech and then press Ctrl F (the find command) and type in the words: The economics of healthcare This takes you to the part of the speech looking at the limitations of the market in allocating healthcare resources. Use this part of the speech to explain these limitations and examine alternative answers to the limitations. |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th and 5th editions), Chapters 10, 11, 12 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapter 6 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 21 |
| On 17 February congestion charging began in central London. Details of the system are given in the first of the following linked articles. But what has been its effect? Who have been the gainers and losers? Will it penalise the poor disproportionately (as some have claimed) or will the poor benefit relative to the better off? These are some of the issues examined in the following articles. |
Congestion charges Guardian (14/2/03)
Take Ken's £5 decongestant medicine and be glad today. It's London's last hope Times Online (17/2/03)
Avoiding gridlock The Economist (17/2/03)
Congestion charge cuts traffic levels BBC News Online (18/2/03)
Where congestion cash goes BBC News Online (19/2/03)
Congestion charge creates boom for suburban shops Independent (22/2/03)
Who really gains...? Guardian (30/1/03)
Transport for London Congestion Charging Home Page
Briefing note on congestion charging from the Institute of Fiscal Studies
| Questions | |
| 1. | Who gain and who lose from the London congestion charging system? Would it be a good idea to raise the charge to £10? |
| 2. | What determines the price elasticity of demand for travel into the congestion zone? |
| 3. | Compare the relative merits of the system in London (an area licence scheme of one payment per day) and the system in Singapore (an electronic toll scheme)? See the final link for details. See also Box 12.4 in Economics (5th ed) or Box 6.5 in Essentials of Economics (2nd ed) or Box 21.1 in Economics for Business (2nd ed). |
| 4. | Referring to The Economist article, what lessons can be learnt from other countries for reducing traffic congestion in cities? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th
edition), Chapters 13, 16
Economics (5th edition), Chapters 13, 17 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapters 7, 8 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 25 |
| February 2003 saw a number of gloomy macroeconomic indicators. Two of these were a decline in output of manufacturing in 2002 and a fall in consumer spending in January. What were the causes of these and what is the outlook for the future? The following articles look at these questions. |
Worst slump since 1991 Guardian (8/2/03)
UK shoppers shunned the sales BBC News Online (20/2/03)
High street sales tumble Ananova (20/3/03)
UK set to beat crisis - Brown Observer (2/2/03)
| Questions | |
| 1. | Why did industrial output drop by 3.5 per cent in 2002, despite a growth in consumer demand? |
| 2. | Why has the growth in consumer spending been slowing recently? |
| 3. | What are the likely to be the major determinants of consumer spending in the next few months? |
| 4. | For what reasons may the UK economy be better placed than most other economies for dealing with turmoil in financial markets and for avoiding recession? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th
edition), Chapters 2, 13, 16
Economics (5th edition), Chapters 2, 13, 17 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapters 2, 7, 8 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapters 4, 25, 28 |
| Many commentators are arguing that war with Iraq is now virtually inevitable, despite the massive anti-war protests around the world, including the march in London on 15 February, which attracted over 1 million protesters. Already the prospect of war is having various effects on the world economy. The following articles look at some of these effects. |
War 'would mean biggest oil shock ever' Observer (2/2/03)
The economic risks The Economist (20/2/03)
The high cost of toppling Saddam Observer (2/2/03)
| Questions | |
| 1. | What would be the likely impact of war with Iraq on oil prices? Why might the effect be of a different magnitude from that of the Gulf War in 1991? |
| 2. | What are the possible types of macroeconomic cost of a war? |
| 3. | Under what circumstances could the US economy slip into a new recession? |
| 4. | What are the likely costs to the UK economy of a war with Iraq and its aftermath? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th
edition), Chapter 14
Economics (5th edition), Chapter 13 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapter 7 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 25 |
| According to the following article, from The Economist of 6 February 2003, "average GDP per head in the European Union, measured at purchasing-power parity, is only three-quarters of that in the United States". Does this mean that the living standard of the average person in the EU is only three-quarters of that in the United States? The article explores whether GDP is a good indicator of living standards. |
Are Europeans really so much worse off than Americans?
| Questions | |
| 1. | For what reasons’ may GDP figures overstate living standards in the USA relative to those in the EU? (Try to extend the reasons beyond those given in the article.) |
| 2. | Should GDP be abandoned as an indicator of a country’s living standards? Give reasons for your answer. |
| 3. | What alternative measures could be used for living standards as alternatives to, or in addition to, GDP? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th
edition), Chapters 16, 18
Economics (5th edition), Chapters 17, 18 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapters 8, 9 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 25, 27 |
| The City of London is in crisis. With many City firms seeing their profits plummeting and with huge job losses, the City is experiencing its worst recession in history. The following article, from The Economist of 6 February 2003, examines the causes of this crisis. |
Goodbye to the City
| Questions | |
| 1. | Who else, other than investment banks, are being affected by the current crisis in the City and why? |
| 2. | What are the causes of the crisis? |
| 3. | Why does merger and acquisition (M&A) activity tend to fall in a recession? |
| 4. | What is likely to happen to City profits and employment in the near future? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th and 5th editions), Chapters 9, 10, 18, 19, 20, 22 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapters 5, 8, 9 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapters 18, 27, 29 |
| With an ageing population, falling stock markets, falling saving and an unwillingness by politicians to raise taxes, there is a growing pensions crisis and a prospect that many will face an old age of poverty. The following two articles look at the causes of the problem and what can be done about it. |
The great pensions lie Observer (16/2/03)
UK pensions crisis poised to deepen Times Online (22/2/03)
| Questions | |
| 1. | Why might increased saving not be a sufficient answer to the future funding of pensions? |
| 2. | Why are so many companies abandoning 'final salary' pension schemes (i.e. schemes where pensioners receive a proportion of their final salary based on the number of years they have contributed to the pension scheme)? |
| 3. | What is the best solution to the problem? |
News Item 13: Is the Bank of England inflation model out of date?
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th and 5th editions), Chapters 19, 20, 21 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapters 9, 10 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapters 27, 28, 29 |
| The Bank of England uses a macroeconometric model on which to base its forecasts of inflation and the state of the economy. It is these forecasts that the Monetary Policy Committee uses to base its monthly interest rate decisions. A new report by Adrian Pagan criticises this model. The following links look at the report and its criticisms. (The third link is to the report itself and the fourth to the Bank of England's response.) |
Bank told inflation model is out of date Guardian (30/1/03)
Bank of England press release (30/1/03)
Pagan report
Bank's response to the Pagan Report
| Questions | |
| 1. | What are the main findings of the Pagan report? |
| 2. | Why have the deficiencies in the Bank of England's quarterly macroeconometric model not had any significant adverse effect on the decisions of the Monetary Policy Committee? |
| 3. | What are the advantages and disadvantages of basing interest rate decisions on forecasts of inflation? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th and 5th editions), Chapters 19, 20 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapter 9 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 29 |
| On 6 February, the Bank of England decided to cut interest rates from 4% to 3.75%. On the same day, it was announced that the ECB had decided to keep eurozone interest rates unchanged at 2.75%. The following articles look at the reasoning behind these decisions? |
Surprise cut in UK interest rates BBC News Online (18/2/03)
Q&A: Surprise interest rate cut BBC News Online (18/2/03)
Frankfurt dithers, London acts The Economist (6/2/03)
Bank cuts interest rates in 'gamble' on economy Times Online (6/2/03)
| Questions | |
| 1. | Why did the Bank of England decide to cut interest rates, given that inflation, at 2.7% was above the target rate of 2.5%? |
| 2. | Why did the ECB decide to keep interest rates on hold? |
| 3. | Argue the case for and against each of these decisions. |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th
edition), Chapters 13, 18, 19, 20, 22
Economics (5th edition), Chapters 14, 18, 19, 20, 22 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapters 7, 9, 10 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapters 25, 27, 29, 30 |
| Is the UK economy heading for a period of deflation, with falling prices and a depressed economy? Until very recently, most economists had thought that such a scenario was unlikely, given that inflation is around 2.7 per cent and shows little immediate sign of falling much below the Bank of England's target of 2.5 per cent. But some commentators are now arguing that, when you look beneath the headline figures, there are some potentially worrying signs. The following article, from the Independent of 22 February, assesses the evidence. |
Threat of deflation looms closer
| Questions | |
| 1. | In what sense is price deflation already a reality in Britain? |
| 2. | Does price deflation matter if it is the result of intense competition from low-cost imports rather than the result of weak demand? |
| 3. | Give some examples of services that face competition from low-cost imports? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th
edition), Chapters 14, 24
Economics (5th edition), Chapters 15, 24 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapter 12 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 26 |
| Figures recently released show that both the UK and USA experienced record trade deficits in 2002. What are the reasons for this and is it necessarily bad news? The following articles look at the figures and assess their significance. |
UK Trade gap hits new record Ananova (10/2/03)
U.S. trade gaps in Dec and 2002 hit record highs Reuters (20/2/03)
US import binge hurts at home, helps global growth Reuters (20/2/03)
| Questions | |
| 1. | What are the causes of the UK's record trade deficit and what are the consequences for the UK economy? How will a depreciation of the US dollar affect the UK's trade deficit? |
| 2. | What are the causes of the USA's record trade deficit? How do these causes differ from those explaining the UK's trade deficit? |
| 3. | Is a record US trade deficit good or bad news for the rest of the world? Explain. |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (4th and 5th editions), Chapters 22-26 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd edition), Chapters 11, 12 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapters 22-24, 31 |
| East Asia experienced an economic crisis in 1997/8, from which several of the countries of the region have found it difficult to recover. What is the economic outlook for the region? What reforms have been instituted and what further reforms are needed? These are questions addressed in the following linked article. It is the first article from a survey of the region appearing in The Economist of 6 February 2003. |
The weakest link
| Questions | |
| 1. | What is meant by the 'demographic dividend' that the region is likely to experience? |
| 2. | What measures were taken in South Korea that helped recovery from the crisis in 1997? |
| 3. | How has the economic and financial situation in Japan affected the region over the past few years? |