| Economics News Articles: February 2004 |
|
Welcome to the February set of news items. February
may be a short month, but there has certainly been no shortage of economics
news articles this month. The dollar has continued to fall (see news
item 14) and trade also has been very much in the news. World trade
talks, known as the Doha round, stalled at Cancun in Mexico over disputes
about agricultural subsidies, but some African nations have been trying
to get the talks back on the rails (see news item 13). However, the
UK balance of payments figures for last year put us even further into
the red and so we look at this issue again in news item 15. Market failure
has also continued to make the news with the congestion charge celebrating
its first anniversary (see news item 5) and Exxon being ordered by a
court in Alaska to pay a $6.75bn settlement in relation to the Exxon
Valdez oil spill (see news item 8). Competition policy has also been
in the news with the supermarkets being investigated to see if the new
code of practice for dealing with suppliers has been working (news item
6) and Ryanair ordered to pay back the subsidies they have received
from the Belgian government for operating through Charleroi airport
(news item 7). |
|
Andy Beharrell
|
| Contents |
1. OPEC - cutting oil production quotas
2. Rolls - cost cutting in production
3. Glaxo - the threat of generic drugs
4. One in 10 workers incompetent?
5. Congestion charge - happy first birthday
6. Supermarket competition code - is it working?
7. Ryanair must pay back subsidies received
8. Exxon Valdez - paying for the clean up
9. The conservative fiscal alternative
10. Replacing the council tax?
11. Interest rates rise - MPC warns on debt
12. Chinese rural spending - supporting the regions
13. Restoring the Doha trade talks
14. The fall, fall and rise of the dollar
15. Further into the red zone - UK trade deficit
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapters 2, 7, 12 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapters 1, 2 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 4, 12 |
| This month OPEC announced a cut in output of 10%. This was a surprise to the markets and led to a jump in oil prices. OPEC (Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries) tries to influence oil prices through the manipulation of oil quotas for each member country. A quota cut of 10% will reduce supply on the world oil market and therefore push up prices. |
OPEC to cut daily production Miami Herald (11/2/04)
Crude soars on OPEC cut The Scotsman (11/2/04)
OPEC will cut output by 10% Boston Globe (11/2/04)
OPEC to cut oil output 10% News.com (11/2/04)
OPEC output cut criticised by US BBC News (11/2/04)
| Questions | |
| 1. | What sort of conditions in a market are likely to lead to the establishment of a cartel? |
| 2. | What other market influences are there on oil prices? |
| 3. | What impact will the increase in the oil price have on the UK economy? |
| 4. | What problems are OPEC likely to face in maintaining these quota reductions? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapter 5 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 3 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 9 |
| Rolls Royce have developed a revolutionary new factory in Glasgow. The new factory will employ 900 rather than 1800 staff and will enable them to reduce unit costs significantly. The new factory is being used as a model for further new factories to be built at Bristol, Derby and Hucknall in Nottinghamshire. The aim is to revive profit growth at the engine manufacturer and help them to gain a competitive advantage in the world aero engine market. |
New Rolls plant blooms Guardian (13/2/04)
Rolls Royce purrs to a two-and-a-half year high The Herald (13/2/04)
| Questions | |
| 1. | What type of costs have Rolls Royce reduced with their 'revolutionary' new factory? |
| 2. | Why is it important for them to reduce engine manufacture times? |
| 3. | Why have Rolls Royce chosen to import over 70% of their components from low-cost producers? What disadvantages might this strategy have? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapters 7, 11,12 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 6 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapters 12, 14, 20, 30 |
| GlaxoSmithKline is one of the world's largest drugs producers. However, they have warned this year that their profits have been hit by the production of generic drugs. These are copies of the branded drugs that Glaxo produce, but made at much lower prices and lower cost. However, the drugs companies argue that they have invested millions in research and development of these drugs and their intellectual property should therefore be protected. These articles look at the impact of the generic drugs market. |
Cheap copies and cheap dollar hurt Glaxo Guardian (13/2/04)
Rival drugs threaten Glaxo sales Guardian (13/2/04)
Copy-cat warning depresses shares in GlaxoSmithKline The Herald (13/2/04)
Rival drugs threaten Glaxo profit BBC News (12/2/04)WTO site - information on trade-related intellectual property rights
| Questions | |
| 1. | Who are the winners and losers from the protection of intellectual property (a) in the short term and (b) in the long term? |
| 2. | Why might government intervention be necessary to protect intellectual property rights? |
| 3. | Examine whether intellectual property rights could be against the interests of competition in a market. |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapter 9 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 5 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapters 17, 20 |
| The most recent skills survey from the Learning and Skills Council has found that one in ten workers do not have the required skills to do their job properly. It also identified a range of skills shortages and other labour market problems. So what can we do to address these problems? The articles below examine the results of the survey, but have a look in detail at the third link as well, which gives a slightly broader picture of the survey. |
One in 10 workers incompetent BBC News (3/2/04)
The cult of competence BBC News (3/2/04)
Learning and Skills Council Employers Skills Survey
| Questions | |
| 1. | What impact will a more skilled workforce have on the marginal revenue product curve (the demand curve for labour)? |
| 2. | Evaluate three different policies for reducing the skills shortages. |
| 3. | What impact will these skills shortages have on the macroeconomy? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapters 11, 12 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 6 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 21 |
| The congestion charge for driving in London had its first birthday this month and remains as controversial as ever. It would appear to have had considerable success in reducing traffic flows and large numbers have switched to the buses and other forms of public transport. However, businesses in the congestion charge area argue that their business is down and some are even shutting up shop. The 'success' of the scheme is leading to many other cities considering introducing similar schemes, but are they premature in their assessment of the scheme? |
Traffic and parking 'more off-putting than congestion charge' The Scotsman (15/2/04)
London companies learn to love congestion charge The Guardian (16/2/04)
First anniversary of controversial congestion charge The Scotsman (17/2/04)
Jury out on congestion charging BBC News (16/2/04)
Business piles blame on congestion charge BBC News (17/2/04)
Ken's moving in the right direction The Telegraph (22/2/04)
Get ready for Kengrad The Guardian (22/2/04)
| Questions | |
| 1. | What forms of market failure led to the Mayor of London introducing a congestion charge? |
| 2. | Assess the impact that the scheme has had in terms of changes in external costs and external benefits. |
| 3. | Assess the impact that the scheme has had on businesses (a) inside the area and (b) outside the area. |
| 4. | How is the national roll-out of such schemes likely to affect the economy? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapter 12 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 6 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapters 12, 16, 20 |
| The growth and market power of the supermarkets has led many to argue that suppliers have been exploited with unfair trading practices. To try to ensure fair competition in the market, the supermarkets and supplier groups agreed two years ago to a code of practice. However, the Office of Fair Trading has admitted that suppliers may be afraid to complain under the code as many are so reliant on the supermarkets for their livelihood. |
OFT sends in auditors as new code fails to break supermarkets' armlock The Guardian (21/2/04)
Major supermarkets face enquiry over supplies The Scotsman (21/2/04)
Code of practice is failing supermarket suppliers The Scotsman (21/2/04)
| Questions | |
| 1. | What alternatives are there to voluntary codes of conduct to ensure fair and free competition in these markets? |
| 2. | To what extent does the market structure of the supermarket industry affect the level of competition? |
| 3. | What potential advantages does a concentrated market structure deliver for consumers? Do these advantages outweigh the potential costs? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapter 12 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 6 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 24 |
| Ryanair have, in many places, been receiving subsidies from the airports that they fly into. The airports, keen to attract visitors into the area, are willing to pay to attract them. The money that visitors bring should have a multiplied effect in the region, more than paying for the cost of the subsidy. However, the EU has ruled that these subsidies are anti-competitive and therefore illegal. Ryanair faces paying the subsidies back. |
Ryanair's wings clipped in crunch EU ruling EU Business (Feb. 04)
Belgium to be ordered to recover Ryanair subsidies Scotsman (3/2/04)
Ryanair slates Charleroi ruling BBC News (3/2/04)
Levelling the runway Guardian (4/2/04)
Depressed region fears Ryanair exit BBC News Online (3/2/04)
Ryanair claims EC ruling will hit budget travel, but rivals doubt it Guardian (4/2/04)
Ryanair chief fights back Guardian (4/2/04)
EC ruling a 'disaster' for Ryanair The Scotsman (4/2/04)
| Questions | |
| 1. | Draw a diagrams to illustrate the impact of the subsidy on (a) the market for air travel and (b) the equilibrium price and output level of Ryanair. |
| 2. | What determines the value of the regional multiplier in the airports that Ryanair fly into? |
| 3. | Why are the subsidies to Ryanair considered anti-competitive? |
| 4. | What is likely to be the impact on the low-cost airline industry of the removal of the subsidies? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapter 12 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 6 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 21 |
| In 1989 the Exxon Valdez tanker ran aground on the Alaskan coast. This resulted in the contamination of 1300 miles of coastline. Since then the accident has been the subject of endless litigation. This $6.75bn settlement is the latest twist in this battle, but the Exxon Corporation have said that they will appeal against the judgement. The final link below is also worth a look. Research from Friends of the Earth suggests that they can calculate the exact contribution of a firm to global warming and the press release looks at how much global warming is attributed to Exxon Mobil. Have a look - you may be surprised. |
Exxon hit with $6.75bn spill bill BBC News (29/1/04)
Exxon told to pay $7bn for oil spill Guardian(29/1/04)
Exxon to pay Alaskans $6.75bn for oil spill The Scotsman (29/1/04)
Judge orders Exxon Mobil to pay nearly $7bn in spill damages Environmental News Network (29/1/04)
Exxon Mobil's contribution to global warning revealed Friends of the Earth press release (29/2/04)
| Questions | |
| 1. | Draw up a list of private costs and private benefits and external costs and external benefits arising from the exploitation of oil. |
| 2. | What market failures are evident from the articles arising from the Exxon Valdez oil spill? |
| 3. | What problems are likely to arise when valuing the external costs that have arisen from the oil spill? |
| 4. | What other market failures are evident from the Friends of the Earth press release (the last link above)? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapter 20 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 8 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 29 |
| With election time in the UK getting ever closer, the various parties are starting to develop their policies. The Conservatives have been the first to announce their approach to fiscal policy with a major speech given by the Shadow Chancellor - Oliver Letwin. They are arguing that government spending should be constrained to a certain percentage of GDP. This will allow for growth in government expenditure, but without adverse effects on tax levels and borrowing. |
Do Letwin's sums add up? BBC News (16/2/04)
Tories unveil economic blueprint BBC News (16/2/04)
Full text of Letwin speech BBC News (16/2/04)
| Questions | |
| 1. | Why are the Tories proposing reducing the share of national income taken up by government expenditure? |
| 2. | What are the disadvantages of high levels of public borrowing? |
| 3. | What impact are the proposed policies likely to have on the government's major macroeconomic objectives? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapter 10, 20 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 8 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 29 |
| The council tax was introduced in 1993 by John Major's government and replaced the unpopular poll tax that Margaret Thatcher's government introduced previously. It is based on property values and the level is set by the local authority. However, it remains unpopular and widely criticised and there has been some discussion this month about replacing it with a local income tax. |
Council tax's future in doubt The Guardian (16/2/04)
Labour draws up plan to scrap council tax The Scotsman (14/2/04)
Council tax to be replaced by new levy on incomes The Telegraph (15/2/04)
| Questions | |
| 1. | What are the disadvantages of the council tax? |
| 2. | Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of changing from a council tax to a system of levies on incomes. |
| 3. | What impact is a change of this nature likely to have on the macroeconomy? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapter 20, 18 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 9 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 29 |
| For the first time for a number of years, interest rates are starting to rise. This month the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the Bank of England raised rates for the second time in 4 months. The Bank has also started to sound warning bells on the levels of consumer debt. |
Bank fires warning shot on debt Guardian (6/2/04)
MPC puts debt fear ahead of exporters' needs The Scotsman (6/2/04)
Lenders raise mortgage rates Ananova (5/2/04)
Britain raise interest rates The Age (6/2/04)
Homeowners hit as bank raises rates to 4% The Scotsman (5/2/04)
How far will the Bank raise interest rates? BBC News online (5/2/04)
UK interest rates rise, but ECB's hold steady International Herald Tribune (6/2/04)
| Questions | |
| 1. | Use the articles to find figures that illustrate why the MPC felt it necessary to increase interest rates. |
| 2. | What impact is the rate increase expected to have on the economy? |
| 3. | Why is the Bank concerned about rising levels of consumer debt? |
| 4. | What is the transmission mechanism by which changes in interest rates impact on aggregate demand? |
News Item 12: Chinese rural spending - supporting the regions
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapter 22 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 11 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 30 |
| Chinese farmers' incomes have been suffering in the last decade and the Chinese government has recognised the problems of the rural areas with a new package of rural spending to improve the lot of the 900 million Chinese farmers. The plan will lead to a record level of spending of $18bn on rural infrastructure. |
China pumps up rural spending BBC News online(9/2/03)
| Questions | |
| 1. | Why has the government felt it necessary to boost spending in rural areas? Why have markets alone not been able to deliver improvements in rural incomes? |
| 2. | What will determine the value of the regional multiplier that will result from these increases in spending? |
| 3. | What are the disadvantages of the government intervening directly to influence economic growth in this way? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapter 23 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 11 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 22 |
| African ministers have met EU ministers and US officials this month to try to restore the WTO trade talks that were stalled in Cancun. Much of the row has related to levels of farm subsidies and this has blocked attempts to get the talks - called the Doha round - started again. The negotiations are due to be completed by the end of the year, but these delays have made it look increasingly unlikely. The articles below look at the attempts by African countries to get the negotiations under way again and the key constraints the talks are facing. |
US pressure on EU over farm aid BBC News Online (20/2/04)
Pro free trade agricultural nations to meet ahead of world trade talks China Post (20/2/04)
US calls for end to EU export aid BBC News Online (20/2/04)
Commonwealth ministers hopeful for WTO revival, but farming key EU Business (18/2/04)
| Questions | |
| 1. | Why are the Doha trade talks considered important? |
| 2. | Why are subsidies seen as a form of protectionist policy? What impact does the policy have on (a) the nation giving the subsidies and (b) nations trying to export to them? |
| 3. | Why have African countries been trying to revive the trade talks? What problems are developing countries likely to face if the Doha trade talks are not resumed? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapter 15, 24 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 12 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 26 |
| The euro, once the weak currency, has gained over 45% against the dollar since July 2001 and the dollar has also been falling against other major currencies like sterling. Why has this been happening and what is the impact on the US and the rest of the world? |
Time for a transatlantic trolley dash? BBC News Online (18/2/04)
Q&A: Why the dollar's in decline BBC News Online (18/2/04)
US basks in dollar decline BBC News Online (7/1/04)
Exchange rates dominate G7 talks BBC News Online (8/2/04)
Dollar rallies after hitting lows BBC News Online (18/2/04)
| Questions | |
| 1. | Why is the USA 'basking in the dollar decline'? |
| 2. | How is the appreciation of sterling likely to affect the UK trade balance (a) in the short term and (b) in the long term? Explain your answer fully considering elasticity of demand for imports and exports where relevant. |
| 3. | How is the appreciation of sterling likely to affect unemployment and inflation in the UK? To what extent are the MPC likely to be taking account of exchange rate changes when making their interest rate decisions (see news item 11)? |
| Relevant to: |
| Economics (5th edition), Chapter 15, 24 |
| Essentials of Economics (2nd and 3rd edition), Chapter 12 |
| Economics for Business (2nd edition), Chapter 26 |
| Last month in the news articles (news item 16) we looked at the worsening monthly trade figures. This month we return to the issue as the annual figures are released and they don't look any more promising! A record deficit of £35.8bn marks a rapid deterioration in our trade performance since 1997, the last time we had a trade surplus. In the article below Larry Elliot from the Guardian looks at our trade performance and examines the extent to which it indicates a poorer economic performance than other indicators suggest. |
It's downhill all the way for UK trade traffic The Guardian (16/2/04)
| Questions | |
| 1. | Should we be concerned about a large trade deficit? |
| 2. | What policy options does the government have to try to improve the trading performance of the UK? What impact are these policies likely to have on the rest of the economy? |
| 3. | The article considers import penetration for certain areas of trade. What is meant by import penetration? What possible policies are available to try to reduce import penetration in the areas mentioned in the article? |
| 4. | What differences are apparent from the article in our trade performance in goods as compared to services? |